Welcome!

It's tough to be an introvert in an extrovert world, especially in an extrovert's profession, like teaching. Through this blog, I'd like to share my own and others' reflections on being an introvert in the classroom. This isn't a place for misanthropes or grumps, though; I hope to thoughtfully discuss the challenges that introverts face in schools and celebrate the gifts that introverted teachers and students bring to the educational environment. If you can relate, please join me!

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Why I love Nicki Minaj

I admit it. I listen to hip-hop. I love hip-hop. It is my favorite thing to listen to, especially when driving to school in the morning. My latest obsession is with Nicki Minaj, but I have all sorts of other embarassing hip-hop CDs tucked into a compartment of my car.

Put simply, I need to get pumped up to be in front of people all day. I liken it to when my mild-mannered suburban high school boys would tell me they listened to rap on the way to compete in a sporting event.

I try to ignore the derisive lyrics, but some of the lyrics are really good. Most contemporary poets are too cool to worry about rhyme and meter anymore, but rappers aren't.

While sometimes hip-hop stars seem to have an unearned braggodoccio, that is, they come from a world where style sometimes rules over substance, I think the agressive self-affirmation of hip-hop artists is just what I need if I'm preparing to discuss Wuthering Heights at 8:00 in the morning. (And a lot of coffee helps, too.)

I know I have earned my authority and credibility, but that doesn't fully explain how I can have the guts to face sleepy and angry teenagers every morning. I need to hear the beats that inspire you in your gut. There is something visceral about teaching. You really need to be fully there, fully present, fully passionate, fully yourself. Charisma is key. I bet many of you can relate to the experience of having taught the same lesson but one day you were "feeling it" or "in the zone" and the next time you weren't, and you can really tell the difference. If I don't give it all of my enthusiasm, class just doesn't "go." I need to be properly pumped up before my performances.

What do you do to get "in the zone" for teaching? Isabel Gillies writes some funny stuff about this in Happens Every Day, a memoir she wrote after she temporarily gave up her acting career in New York to become an adjunct drama teacher at Oberlin College in Ohio, where her husband and the father of her two children got a full-time job there (he would then proceed to cheat on her with a colleague). The book was popular when Starbucks was featuring books in their stores a couple of years back.

Yep, for those early-morning classes, bring on the Starbucks. And while my more respectable colleagues are doing tai chi, I prefer to blast the hip-hop. I get a surge of courage from  the pink-haired "little black girl" (as she referred to herself on the recent E! Special that I did watch--another admission--) from the streets of New York who bosses around the tough guys.

Saturday, November 24, 2012

I've had my socks made fun of.

Lots of people lament the decline of civility in our society. But sometimes people have a shallow understanding of what that means. I don't mean it would be "nice" if people said "please" and "thank you" more often.

I mean that we are living in a world where a fifteen-year-old made fun of my socks. How can I be my true self, how can I be present and really be there for the kids if I have to worry about being disrespected on such a fundamental level? I've certainly had much worse things said to me, but for some reason the "socks" thing really stings. I think it's because nobody wants to look like a dork, and that fear runs really deep all through life.

I was wearing socks because it was 2000 and I was teaching at a California high school in which all the classroom doors opened up to outdoor hallways and it was freaking cold at 8:00 a.m. and therefore I couldn't not wear socks under my hippy-chic / professional long skirt from the '90s. I thought the length of the skirt hid the socks adequately. I was wrong.

This person who made fun of my socks (and gave me all sorts of other grief) was eventually classified as "gifted at-risk" and accepted into what is called a "middle college," or a high school housed on a college campus.

When I first heard of such schools, I thought it was a neat concept. High school sucks for smart kids, and how cool that someone finally saw that and made an alternative place for us! Oh, except not for me, because I was not only smart but also respectful, and that respectfulness would have been stereotyped as submissiveness.

I'm troubled by what I see as a trend of confusing acting like a jerk with having something to say. I even took an interview for a teaching position at this middle college high school, and they flat-out said that they wanted the student who will argue with the teacher. Now, a good teacher will invite students to argue with her intellectually. But I had the feeling they meant merely the student who challenges authority just for the sake of challenging authority.

I saw Dr. Jeffrey Duncan-Andrade speak at Mt. SAC last spring, and he was talking about the disruptive student in the back of the class, and how that student "has so much heart." I think an extrovert who is smart or hurt may show it by acting out, but I worry that some educators seem to believe that all who act out are smart, hurt extroverts. The thinking seems to go something like this: the more trouble-maker-ish you are, the more interesting/smart/hurt/worthy of attention you must be. Could it be that sometimes people act out because they are jerks? I am troubled by the idea that acting like a jerk is acceptable if you have a good reason.


It's not acceptable to be a jerk just because you're smart. Or because somebody hurt you. Two wrongs don't make a right.

Don't make fun of my socks, man.


Finally, I think acting out in response to grief is a behavior particular to extroverts. By only focusing on the jerks' problems, what happens to the introverts? I suspect the introverts are the ones that punish themselves, not others, for their pain. I suspect it's not the extroverted trouble-maker who falls through the cracks, who gets depression, who self-harms. Who's looking out for those kids?




Friday, November 23, 2012

I teach English.

There are two kinds of high school English teachers. There are the ones who say things like, "I don't teach English; I teach kids!" and then there are the ones who roll their eyes when they hear stuff like that. The introvert knows content but is stereotyped as weak or boring; the extrovert does not usually have the same content-area preparation but is, as Willy Loman said, "Well liked."

Content is, as I've explained in other posts, often brushed off because you can "use" any literature to teach a "process," whether it be writing, critical thinking, or interacting with others. But I think it's still about the content. After all, look at the alternatives.

If education is all about the teacher, we have a dictatorship. If it is all about the student, we have narcissism. You shouldn't hold blindly onto some fixed canon from the good old days nor should class be a big therapy session for students obsessed with the ephemeral.

The content is life. The content is the great conversation that people have been engaging in for eons about how to live a good life. If a class is focused on that, both students and teachers learn.

"Do you actually like grading papers?"

A student asked me this the other day. He's probably heard every teacher he's ever had complain about grading papers.

You would think a bunch of introverted, content-loving professors would love to run out of class and cozy up to some reading material, but we often don't. Even a self-proclaimed introvert colleague said to a group of us, "No one goes into teaching because they want to grade papers. Everyone wants to be in the classroom."

I have a few hypotheses about why even the most introverted among us sometimes hate grading papers (and I think much of this applies also to why online teaching is not as fulfilling as face-to-face even though it's all reading, supposedly an introvert's dream):

  • We need to get our students writing a lot so that every once in awhile there's a great burst of insight. Writing involves a lot of "throat-clearing" before you get anything good out. I think a CSUN prof is responsible for that metaphor. So, while we understand that we have to read a lot of "eh" writing, it's not something we look forward to. 
  • There are so many students and you have to go so fast. 
  • You can't just read or even just read and comment; you have to grade. There are so many factors to consider in writing. My rubric is a page long. And that's the abbreviated one. There's the constant stress of "Was I fair?" "Am I consistent with how I was grading yesterday?" This is especially bad for highly sensitive people or those who are constantly analyzing their inner workings. 
  • Most importantly, introverts are not cold-hearted misanthropes. I want to see my students smile. I  want them to laugh at my jokes. I want to see the twinkle in their eyes when they get an idea. It's not that I don't want to talk to people. I want to talk to people in coherent ways. I want a classroom where only one person is talking at one time and we're all engaging in the same discussion. 
Diana Senechal (in Republic of Noise) and Neil Postman (in his Amusing Ourselves to Death discussion of how 19th-century people used to attend three-hours-long lectures voluntarily) both have discussed how, oddly enough, a large group discussion or a lecture can appeal to the introvert. It has to do not with the number of people present but with the singular focus that exists in a whole-class discussion or in a lecture. 

It has occurred to me that the idea that I, an introvert, prefer whole-class discussion to group work could be viewed as paradoxical. In a sense, I ought to love small group work. Isn't it supposed to let me make more individual connections with students? Doesn't it make more sense for an introvert to want to communicate with a small group rather than a whole class? Isn't it a fact that introverts like to connect with fewer students more deeply than with more students less deeply? I think why I disliked group work for so long was because I could not focus on one single group at any given time. I felt I had to constantly circulate and eavesdrop and worry about what everyone was doing. I felt like I had to be in five places at once, or move from place to place, switching gears constantly. (This may be a hold-over from worrying about classroom control all the time in a society where the teacher is always supposed to stimulate and entertain the students and students left to their own devices will default to "goofing off.")  I enjoy group work most when I can turn off the "worrying about everyone" switch in my brain, spend ten to fifteen minutes with a single group, and engage deeply in their discussion. I explain why I want to spend focused time on each group and will not interrupt that and run over to another group if I suspect misbehavior. It's their education, and I'm not abandoning a good discussion to go police some goof-offs. They need to take responsibility. Just as a focused teacher deserves focused students, focused students deserve a focused teacher. 


I have a problem with "I-messages."

"You didn't interpret the theme of this text" = mean :( and will only make the student defensive, according to current educational and psychological theory.

"I do not see evidence of the theme" = better, supposedly.

Of course, as you've guessed, I disagree. Recently, as a student was arguing with me about a grade on an essay, I didn't talk about what I thought. I did not talk about the essay as if it were a separate entity from me and the student ("there's no theme here," "this paper has no thesis," etc.). Out of frustration, I finally used "you." "You misunderstood this text." "You used this word incorrectly." And it felt so good.

It felt good because before we were arguing about the grade that "I" gave. Problem = mine. Or, we were arguing about "the essay." Problem = negotiable, as if the essay were a piece of used furniture whose price we should haggle over, as if perception could determine its value. Students who argue passionately, persistently, or emotionally feel that they are as entitled to judge the essay as I am. The medium (snippity-ness, resentment, anger/intimidation, sympathy-appealing, etc.) is supposed to outweigh the (illogical, invalid, dare I say incorrect--what an absolutist I am!) message. In an extrovert society, you're supposed to speak up for yourself. Advocate for yourself. Make people listen to you. Don't look within yourself or ask what you did wrong. Intimidate your introverted teacher so that she will wonder if she, indeed, was unfair in some way.

What about asking questions: "What can I do to make this paper better?" not, "This is good as it is, why can't you see that?!" Throwing the problem back onto the teacher.

So, in an effort to put the onus back on the student, I used "you-messages." He could argue with what "I" saw and what grade "the essay" deserved but he couldn't say what "he" had done well. Telling, isn't it? At that point, when he could no longer deny himself as the writer and the one who needed to do the learning, he stopped arguing. When he stopped talking, he could start listening to and learning from my suggestions for a rewrite.


"Paper Tigers"

This is the title of one of my favorite articles; it is authored by Wesley Yang, and one extremely dedicated online student recommended it to me about a year ago. See the New York Magazine article here. While this article is about Asians in particular, I think you could replace every instance of the word "Asian" with the word "introvert" and gain a lot of insight. (I am not the only one to make this Asian-introvert analogy. In Quiet, Susan Cain visits a predominantly Asian-American Silicon Valley high school to see what a culture that values introversion is like. She treats the high school as a microcosm of an introvert-centric society.)

Yang discusses the "bamboo ceiling," which is, of course, a play on the "glass ceiling," that is, any un-talked-about barrier that prevents a certain group from advancing in the workplace (although Yang discusses areas of life outside of work as well). His argument is that Asians' strong work ethic, attention to detail, and sense of community (as opposed to the Western superstar individualist) make them excel at technical tasks, but in our extroverted American society, it's not technical knowledge that gets paid the big bucks. Promotions go to managers: people who can talk about how great they are.

When I first started teaching, and people didn't yet know that they'd get their heads bitten off for asking, they'd say, "Oh, maybe someday you can move up into administration." That would be my worst nightmare. I don't want to manage people who get to talk about content all day. I want to be the one who gets to talk about content all day. That's why I became an English teacher. Now, my dean comes from a psychology background, so managing people is part of her "content" background, so it's a good fit. But for other types of faculty, like those who know a lot about Shakespeare or chemistry or Latin or calculus or lots of other stuff, it probably wouldn't be a good idea to put those people in charge of other people. The disciplines that they've devoted their lives to require them to enjoy solitary, focused, detail-oriented work. They would not enjoy constant interruptions, conflict management, and "fighting" for their status among other campus groups. These are extroverted tasks.

The thing is that both kinds of tasks are important. We need people who focus on what Yang calls technical skills or what I would call "content." We also need extroverts who can sell our ideas and programs to the power-brokers. I am thankful there are people willing to do my dean's job. The problem in society (and in education) occurs when the extroverts receive higher prestige and higher pay. That's where the "bamboo ceiling" comes in. The introvert/Asian invents the technology or teaches the Shakespeare but does not get the higher-paying job because this goes to an extrovert who can "sell" it.

Remember the Peter Principle? Laurence Peter said that people will be promoted until they reach a position that they are incompetent to fill, and this usually happens because the higher position requires a different personality type. Will we introverts always be lower on the American career food chain than the extroverts?  

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

"University Frump"

Another phrase/idea I've stolen from Tom McCambridge. Perfect. I saw plenty of displays of university frump at the NCTE Conference in Las Vegas this weekend.

Yes, Las Vegas. Even Sherman Alexie made jokes about English teachers in Las Vegas as he gave his talk at the Secondary Section Luncheon. Besides our name badges, here's how you could tell us apart from other visitors: the preponderance of long skirts, bulky sweaters, hunched posture due to full tote-bags, and awake-ness at early hours of the morning. We've got coffee cups in our hands, not cocktails. We wear low-heeled shoes.

At the same time, I hope I didn't look too frumpy. I've always enjoyed taking care of my appearance. I love doing my nails. I wear makeup every day. If I know there are holes in my clothes, I do not wear them out. Mmmm-hmmm. You know who you are!

There is a clear bias among college faculty against those who dress well. The implication is that if you take time on your appearance, you must be either not devoting enough time to your studying/grading and/or you must be a shallow and materialistic person.

Sometimes I think that it's just that some people like playing with clothes and makeup and some people don't. Period. If you don't, that's fine, but don't try to make up a moral reason why you don't and then use it to look down on others.

But maybe there's more to it. As a highly sensitive person, I have always been sensitive to my environment. Is not my body part of my environment? I like feeling colorful and polished. It keeps my mood up. Just as I might be depressed by grungy orange carpet (WHS, I'm talking to you), I'd also be depressed by grungy yellow fingernails. I'm extremely detail-oriented. Why is it so surprising that a person who can spot a missing period in an MLA citation from a mile away would be similarly irked by a scuff on her shoe?

I think the thinking is that we professorly introverts live life in the mind. I think it was in Sir Ken Robinson's TED talk that he said that professors see their bodies as useful only for transporting their heads from place to place. There's of course the Western body-mind dichotomy. But if God gave us bodies, we're probably not supposed to ignore them. I also reject the materialist accusation; people have been adorning themselves since the beginning of time, long before our consumerist age.

I think Susan Cain (Quiet) and Temple Grandin (Thinking in Pictures: My Life with Autism) are instructive on this point. Both of them trace the introvert's caution and attention to detail back to our animal ancestors. One of them pointed out that if a deer doesn't remember the last place it saw a lion, it will be devoured. This may explain why some people are so attuned to physical details. It was necessary for our survival for a long time. Any small change in the environment could signal danger. In current times in an affluent country, where we don't face survival-threatening danger every day, the meticulousness of highly sensitive people marks them as odd. In a society that values people looking relaxed and having fun at all times, meticulous people get branded as "anal" or "OCD."